Critical Situation for Job Seeking Seamen

A few words about greed, nationalism, dishonesty, and nepotism in the seafaring business.

Jan S., Dec 24, 2018

Looking at the AIS live vessel tracking it is hard to believe how many vessels are underway on the seas. Every vessel needs a full crew and additionally a reliever crew consisting of seamen, engine officers, and deck officers beginning from the youngest 3rd mate and ending on the most experienced of them: the master. Because of that it is also hard to believe how difficult is it to find the job on one of the vessels.

This question is very difficult to answer, because when looking for the job, many things happen that are hard to explain.

First of all, nobody wants to employ a beginner, i.e. newly graduated 3rd or 2nd mates. There are many vacancies for chief mates and masters as well as senior officers with minimum 12 months officer experience. Shipping companies have sometimes very big difficulties with finding skilled experienced chief mate. It is quite easy to promote to a chief mate a confident 2nd mate, who has been working for the company for a quite long time. Following this idea,  people would have very good career opportunities and the motivation to go forward. It would be also a chance for the newcomers to start the career because of new openings for 3rd mates. In a few years, young officers could become a very good chief mates and masters (min. 3 years after completion of maritime university). Unfortunately shipping companies have a very big problem with beginners. Almost nobody of the freshly graduated students have the chance to join a vessel as an officer. The given reason for it is the lack of experience of the candidate. It is very strange because some time ago, shipping companies were fighting to get every student they could. What happened during the last years that nobody is no longer interested in students and graduates? Was the navigational education better and the graduates had more experience after finishing the maritime university? Absolutely not! The graduates are exactly as well educated as before, and ready to fulfill the role of a 3rd mate like before. So the problem must be coming from the side of the shipping companies. Exactly on the way how do they recruit their 3rd officers. Just only a few cadets have the chance to stay as an officer on their cadetship or by the company where they did their practical training, obligatory for every student.

It is best to get a job directly after graduation. In such a case, the graduate knows very well the vessels, internal working procedures, and documents of by the company. Unfortunately the companies are not interested to educate cadets/trainees or they let go the upcoming officers after completion of the onboard training. From the perspective of a European cadet, it is a big problem. Companies are looking for other, cheaper officer as an alternative. Foreign, officers have a lot of disadvantages. The first and the most important of it, is that the foreign candidates are absolutely unknown for the further employer. Therefore the companies await young foreign officers with experience as a warranty for enough skills and knowledge. Is the experience alone a good indicator for a good officer? In most cases is the “experience” equal to the time spent on board. If the sea service times given on CV are real and honestly listed by the applicant, then there remains the question of how does he/she have spent the time onboard. Some seamen have very poor interests in their work and despite long time spent on the ship do not show good knowledge and abilities every officer should have.

Particularly difficult situation is that of graduates who want to work on a tanker. Through the employment matrixes given by the shipping company and indirectly from the oil companies – vetting inspection, an employment for a newcomer 3rd mate is absolutely impossible. The requirements say, a person who applies for a 3rd mate position must have a minimum of 6 months experience in ships type (tanker) and rank (3rd mate) and ships size. Assuming that there is no lower rank officer on board of some vessel as a 3rd mate, it is impossible to get a job on this position.

Usually the 3rd mate is the youngest as a freshly graduated officer coming directly from the maritime university, who has never before been working on the ship in this rank. Following the idea of matrix employment, tanker companies will accept only 3rd mate applicant, who has been working as a 3rd mate by some other tanker company. At this moment the discrepancy should be clearly visible: every 3rd mate was one day a beginner. So how could he get the job on the tanker for the first time without appropriate experience in ship types and rank? Until now nobody was able to explain to me this contradictory situation. The most of contacted tanker companies do not give any answer to this question. Under pretext that they do not conduct direct recruitment they do forward this question to the appropriate crewing agencies supplying the ship’s crew. The question of how to get the job as a 3rd mate for the first time on a tanker remains also without an answer. But all over the world, there are actually a lot of 3rd mates working on tankers.
Thanks to the experience with working ways of Polish crewing agencies, there will be visible one chance for starting the career, beside cheating and adding more vessels to one's CV. The sad truth is that a lot of jobs are reserved only for friends or family members of the crewing agency workers. Thanks to the connections, a privileged group of people always knows at first hand about the newest vacancies. The consequence of it is the most of vacancies will be nowhere published. On the other side vacancies visible for everybody shall do only illusion of possible job opportunities and honest working way of the agency. Much worse is the fact that some agencies are able to hire their friends, even if they do not fulfill requirements concerning experience, expected form other job seekers, who have no connections.

 To give some negative answer to the applicant from outside the agencies do not answer on e-mails, ignore phone calls, or use some pretexts such as "not enough experience", "the ship owner does not agree", "there is no available position" (despite the post on the Internet), or "there was a better candidate" (some friend or a family member). The working way of Polish agencies is a very big problem, because they do supply crew to many European shipping companies and some other all over the world. Unfortunately shipping companies do not know about this problem or just ignore it, so that the chances for getting the job by your typical applicant remain low.
The situation is a little bit different when the shipping companies conduct direct crewing by themselves. In such rare cases, recruits will be mostly only own national seafarers. This means that British Companies recruit only British people, Danish companies Danish people, German companies Germans, etc. It sounds like an advantage for people looking for a job by some shipping company in their own country. On the other hand, it is a very big obstacle for all other European people living in foreign countries, looking for a job on the sea. A very good example of such situation is Germany. In this country foreign people looking for a job, are not really welcome by shipping companies, particularly when there is some vacancy for a ship going under the German flag. In this case even the German officer license bought on some German maritime school and long term stay in German does not help for the foreigner.

The most interesting is the fact that even the good job experience does not help. Everywhere around the Europe, it is the job experience that is most important as an official employment factor, but not in Germany. It may sound unbelievable, but German companies do prefer candidates coming directly from one of the German maritime schools, without practical officer experience. Unfortunately the explanation for it is very simple: money. For every employed newcomer the shipping company is able receive some money from the foundation “Schifffahrtsstandort Deutschland”. The duration of funding is limited up to maximum 64 months, beginning from the date of graduation. Because of that, it is the best for the company to employ somebody directly after graduation. In this case the company will get the money for a longer period. Automatically more experienced people are unwanted because they do not bring money or they bring it for a short time only. Very interesting is what happens with a happy newcomer after 64 Months. Following this financial policy of greed, such people are often fired and replaced by cheaper officers, chief mates, masters from Romania, Ukraine, Russia, India or Philippines. The German companies love very much the international crew, when their own people don’t bring additional money. The most important fact is that the international crews are as cheap as possible.

Despite this critical situation for job seeking seamen, there are still people who are determined to do this hard job and work on a vessel. It is very sad that the access to the maritime jobs is for a lot of them totally blocked because of missing connections or wrong nationality. This is a serious disease affecting shipping companies, their crewing departments, and crewing agencies. The affected people are mostly young and deprived of hope. They are not able to fight against this situation and the help is coming from nowhere.


About the author: Jan S. is a talented user of SuperMemo from Poland. In high school, he decided to learn German and English using the program. He then successfully passed exams to study in a German maritime school. His story is based on his own example. Despite his fantastic qualifications, his dream of becoming a captain of a tanker is only slowly coming to fruition through blood, sweat and tears. His words "help is coming from nowhere" made us think that we could publish his story and hopefully help other young people understand the problem of young job seeking seamen.