This is SuperMemo's cache of the original article from 1999.
The original
article can be found
here.
Learning by Degrees
by Craig Lambert
November-December 2009
Keywords
higher education, medical education, pedagogical methods
The image is grim: “binge and purge” learning. It’s what students do
when they cram for a test: consume subject matter in a large lump (binge) and
then spit it back on the exam (purge). This mode of study doesn’t seem to
produce durable learning. During the past four years, associate professor of
surgery B. Price Kerfoot, M.D. ’96, Ed.M. ’00, has developed a scheme that’s
more like grazing: “spaced education.” More than 10 rigorous studies on medical
students and residents using randomized trials have shown its efficacy: it can
increase knowledge by up to 50 percent, and strengthen retention for up to two
years. Furthermore, students report enjoying spaced education; its website (www.spaceded.com)
even calls it “addictive.”
The website offers, online, the first courses
structured in this mode. (Harvard has applied for a patent on the technology,
and already licenses it to an Internet start-up company, SpacedEd.) The
methodology, which Kerfoot, a urological surgeon, invented, breaks information
down into discrete packages and then applies two learning principles that he
gleaned from the psychological literature on learning and memory. The first
principle is the spacing effect—“When you present and repeat information over
intervals of time [as opposed to “binges”], you can increase the uptake of
knowledge,” he explains. “And it’s encoded in ways that cause it to be
preferentially retained.” The second principle is the testing effect: “When you
present information in a ‘test’ format, rather than just reading it, long-term
retention is dramatically improved.”
Kerfoot had his interest in
education and educational reform sparked when, as a student, he took part in the
Medical School’s New Pathways curriculum. During his residency, he also earned a
master’s degree at the Graduate School of Education. He knew that Web-based
teaching modules are a gold standard for online education, but in a study done
at four medical schools, Kerfoot found that “most students hated them and
long-term retention was quite poor. Why waste a week of their time and $1,000 of
their tuition teaching them about a medical subspecialty when the knowledge will
disappear from memory in five to 12 months?”
In contrast, spaced
education “turns online education on its head,” he asserts. Instead of a test at
the end of the course, it presents the material itself entirely in a
test-question format. New information appears when the correct answer is
explained and elaborated upon. (The online courses have an “answer blog” at the
conclusion of each explanation, for students’ comments and discussion.)
Typically, a course contains 20 to 40 questions, spread across one to two
months. The spacing depends on the student’s answers: an incorrectly answered
question might repeat one week later, for example, and a correctly answered one
after three weeks. After two consecutive correct answers, a question is retired.
Close to home, Kerfoot used Spaced Ed to improve prostate-cancer
screening by 95 primary-care providers at the Veterans Administration Medical
Center in Jamaica Plain, where he works. Participants showed a 26 percent
decrease in inappropriate cancer screenings, saving money and minimizing
patients’ anxiety. (The SpacedEd website offers discussion boards where students
can hash out controversial medical practices like the prostate-specific antigen
[PSA] test.) Kerfoot is also going global, having just completed a
spaced-education randomized trial on urology clinical-practice guidelines
involving 1,470 surgeons in 63 countries.
There are now dozens of courses
on the SpacedEd website, which went live in May. Many are for doctors and
medical students, but there are also offerings on bartending, iPhone tips, and
music theory (which includes video of the instructor playing his guitar in each
question). Nearly all are free; a few have very modest fees—$1.99 to $9.99.
Kerfoot feels that the platform can work with almost any type of course,
including K-12 education, and plans to enlist teachers all over the world to
develop the curriculum, with course authors keeping 60 to 80 percent of the
revenue if there is a tuition fee. His ambition is to cultivate a “social
learning community” where course authors and students interact online, becoming
engaged in creative and effective courses and generating comment and discussion
on the curricular topic. “Our goal is to get the methodology out beyond the
Harvard firewall,” he says. He’d also love to see a course in Spanish, which he
has studied three times previously. As he says, “I won’t have to forget it a
fourth time.”